If a court orders the parties to mediate, it almost always orders them to mediate in good faith. The same phrase appears in contract mediation clauses, employment policies, and state statutes. Yet ask three lawyers what "good faith" means in a mediation setting and you will get three answers. Some courts treat the requirement as a duty to show up. Others see it as a duty to bargain seriously, to send a representative with settlement authority, to follow agreed procedures, and even to make a reasonable offer. The line between hard bargaining and bad faith is fuzzy, and the consequences for crossing it can include sanctions, attorney fee awards, and adverse trial rulings.
This guide explains what good faith mediation actually requires under federal and state law, how courts have applied the standard in real cases, and how to protect yourself from a sanction motion. We pull from the Uniform Mediation Act framework, leading state cases such as Foxgate Homeowners' Ass'n v. Bramalea California, Inc., 26 Cal. 4th 1 (2001), and patterns we see across mediations on our platform.
What "Good Faith" Means in a Mediation Context
There is no single federal definition of good faith mediation. The phrase shows up in three different legal sources, and each source treats it slightly differently.
- Court orders and local rules. Many federal district courts and state trial courts impose a "good faith participation" requirement under their alternative dispute resolution (ADR) local rules. These rules typically require attendance, preparation, and meaningful engagement, without specifying a settlement outcome.
- Contract clauses. Many commercial contracts say the parties must "negotiate in good faith" before suing or arbitrating. Courts enforce these clauses, sometimes dismissing or staying lawsuits filed in violation.
- State statutes and rules of professional conduct. Some state mediation statutes use the phrase directly. Most do not — instead, the duty is read into general procedural rules.
The common thread across all three sources is that good faith mediation refers to conduct, not outcomes. A party can refuse to settle and still act in good faith. A party can show up willing to write a check and still act in bad faith if they hide information or send the wrong person.
What Counts as Good Faith Participation
Courts and ethics committees that have addressed the mediation good faith requirement tend to identify the same core elements.
Attendance by the Right Person
Sending a junior representative with no authority is the classic bad faith move. Most courts require the party with settlement authority — the actual decision-maker — to attend in person or by video, and to remain for the entire session. For an insurance carrier, that means an adjuster with authority up to the policy limits. For a corporation, that means an officer or in-house counsel who can sign a settlement. For a government agency, that means someone who can recommend acceptance without going back through a multi-week approval chain.
Preparation
A party who arrives without having read the case file, reviewed key documents, or thought through settlement parameters is rarely treated as having mediated in good faith. Many local rules require pre-mediation statements, document exchange, and identification of decision-makers in advance. Failing those procedural steps puts a party on weak ground if the mediation collapses and the other side files a sanctions motion.
Honest Disclosure of Material Facts
The duty of good faith does not require giving away strategy, but it does generally forbid affirmative misrepresentation. A party who tells the mediator that a witness will testify a certain way, knowing the witness has recanted, has acted in bad faith. The American Bar Association's Model Rules of Professional Conduct, particularly Rule 4.1, prohibit lawyers from making false statements of material fact to a third person in the course of representing a client. That includes mediators.
Meaningful Engagement
Most courts require parties to make at least some movement during a mediation, or to explain credibly why no movement is possible. A party who arrives, makes a single offer, and refuses every subsequent communication is in dangerous territory. Engagement is judged by conduct: number of offers made, willingness to caucus, response to the mediator's proposals, and tone of communication.
What Courts Treat as Bad Faith
Court opinions on bad faith mediation tend to cluster around the same fact patterns.
- Failure to send a representative with authority. Multiple federal district courts have sanctioned parties — particularly insurers — for sending claims handlers who had to phone a supervisor for every decision.
- Withholding mandatory pre-mediation statements. Parties who skip required submissions, or file them so late that the mediator cannot prepare, have been sanctioned in employment and civil rights cases.
- Refusing to caucus or to make any offer. A "we are here, but we will not negotiate" posture is the textbook bad faith pattern. Courts have held this constitutes a failure to mediate at all.
- Making affirmative misrepresentations. A 2018 federal magistrate's opinion sanctioned a defendant who told the mediator no relevant insurance coverage existed when it did. The misrepresentation became known later in discovery.
- Walking out without notice. A party who leaves a court-ordered session prematurely without a credible reason can face sanctions and adverse evidentiary rulings.
The Confidentiality Conflict
Here is where the law gets complicated. To prove bad faith, the moving party usually has to describe what happened inside the mediation. But mediation communications are protected by confidentiality statutes — UMA Section 4 in adopting states, California Evidence Code §§ 1115–1128, Florida Statute § 44.405, and dozens of similar provisions elsewhere.
The leading case is Foxgate Homeowners' Ass'n v. Bramalea California, Inc., 26 Cal. 4th 1 (2001), in which the California Supreme Court held that the state's mediation confidentiality statute barred sanctions based on conduct that occurred inside the mediation, even when that conduct looked like bad faith. The court reasoned that allowing post-mediation testimony about what was said would gut the confidentiality protections that make mediation work in the first place.
Other states have split. Some follow Foxgate and effectively make bad faith sanctions impossible in pure mediation conduct cases. Others — particularly federal courts applying their own ADR rules — have held that compliance with procedural requirements (attendance, authority, submission of statements) can be enforced because the violations occur outside the protected mediation communications.
The practical takeaway: where confidentiality is robust, bad faith claims based on what was said in the room rarely succeed. Bad faith claims based on attendance, authority, and procedural compliance — things that can be proven without quoting from the session — succeed much more often.
Bad Faith Mediation Consequences
Courts that find bad faith have a range of sanctions available. Common consequences include:
- Monetary sanctions. The bad faith party pays the other side's mediation fees, attorney fees for the mediation day, and travel costs.
- Attorney fee awards on the underlying litigation. Some courts have shifted fees for related motion practice.
- Adverse evidentiary rulings. A bad faith party may face limits on its trial evidence or be denied certain motions.
- Striking of pleadings. In extreme cases, a court can strike answers or enter default, though this is rare.
- Referral to disciplinary authorities. When the bad faith involves misrepresentation by counsel, courts may refer the matter to state bar discipline committees.
- Loss of insurance coverage. Some insurance policies require good faith mediation; failure can affect indemnity obligations.
For contractual mediation clauses, the consequences are different. A party who sues without first mediating in good faith may face a stay of the lawsuit until mediation completes, dismissal without prejudice, or a finding that they cannot recover certain damages.
How Good Faith Varies by State
Practitioners should expect significant state-by-state variation.
- California. Strong confidentiality under Evidence Code §§ 1115–1128 and Foxgate. Sanctions based on in-session conduct are essentially barred; procedural sanctions remain available.
- Florida. Florida Statute § 44.405 protects mediation communications. Florida Rule for Certified and Court-Appointed Mediators imposes ethical good faith duties on the mediator, distinct from party duties.
- Texas. Civil Practice and Remedies Code § 154.073 protects mediation communications; courts have sanctioned parties for failure to attend or send appropriate representatives.
- New York. Court-annexed ADR programs have local good faith rules. New York does not generally impose a duty to negotiate in good faith in the absence of a contract clause.
- Federal. District courts vary widely. Many have local ADR rules with explicit good faith requirements. The Seventh Circuit has been particularly active in enforcing them.
Before relying on the standard in any specific dispute, check the applicable local rules, the relevant state mediation statute, and any contract mediation clause that controls.
How to Protect Yourself From Bad Faith Claims
Even parties who plan to negotiate hard can protect themselves with a few simple practices.
- Confirm attendance and authority in writing before the session. A short pre-mediation email confirming who will attend and what authority they hold defuses most procedural bad faith claims.
- Comply with every procedural rule. Submit the pre-mediation statement on time. Exchange documents as required. Show up on time and stay for the scheduled period.
- Document offers and counters in writing. Keep a record of every offer made and every response received. If a bad faith claim is filed later, your record (not your testimony about the session) will support your defense.
- Use the mediator as a buffer. If you cannot make a higher offer because of a coverage limit, a board decision, or a regulatory constraint, tell the mediator the constraint. The mediator can communicate the reason to the other side without exposing your strategy.
- Notify the mediator before walking out. If you must end the session early, explain why on the record before leaving. A documented business reason is much harder to attack than an unexplained departure.
How Mediation.net Can Help
We design our platform to support the procedural elements of good faith mediation. Authority and attendance are confirmed during intake. Pre-mediation statements and document exchange happen through our secure interface, with timestamps that create a clean record. Offer and counter exchanges are logged in the system so each party has a verifiable history of the negotiation.
We assign mediators trained in subject-matter specifics and in the ethical standards that govern mediator conduct under state and federal rules. For organizations that want predictable compliance with mediation clauses across multiple disputes, our Annual Mediation Membership provides ongoing access. For one-off disputes, our Case Mediation service handles the full process from claim opening to settlement signature.
To talk through a mediation good faith requirement that applies to your matter, visit mediation.net or give us a ring at (888) 885-5060.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is good faith mediation legally required?
It depends on the source. Court-ordered mediation generally requires good faith participation under the relevant local rules. Contract mediation clauses can also create a good faith obligation enforceable in court. There is no general federal common-law duty of good faith mediation outside these sources.
What is considered bad faith in mediation?
Common examples include sending a representative without settlement authority, refusing to make any offer, failing to submit required pre-mediation materials, making affirmative misrepresentations of material fact, and walking out without explanation. Hard bargaining and refusal to settle on terms a party finds unacceptable are not bad faith.
Can I be sanctioned for not settling at mediation?
No. Refusal to settle, by itself, is not bad faith. Courts have repeatedly held that parties retain the right to reject any offer. Sanctions are tied to procedural violations (attendance, authority, preparation) and to misrepresentations, not to the substance of settlement positions.
How is good faith proven if mediation is confidential?
Through evidence that does not require disclosure of mediation communications: attendance records, written authority confirmations, document exchange logs, and offer histories preserved outside the session. Where states have strong confidentiality statutes (notably California after Foxgate), proof based on what was said inside the session is generally barred.
How do I file a mediation with documented good faith protections?
You can open a case on our platform at mediation.net or phone us at (888) 885-5060. Our intake process captures attendance, authority, and procedural compliance in writing, so both sides have a verifiable record of their participation.
This guide is general information. It is not legal advice.